StayMarquis
Where Montauk slows down, just steps from the water
Reserve this StayFort Pond Fantastic
Fort Pond Fantastic sits on a quiet stretch of Montauk where the landscape feels unhurried and the water is never far from view. This private residence occupies a privileged position near Fort Pond, one of the area's most serene natural features, offering a sense of seclusion that feels increasingly rare on the East End of Long Island. The architecture is clean and contemporary, designed to frame the surrounding greenery and light rather than compete with it. From the moment you arrive, the property reads as a place built for decompression, where every room opens toward something worth looking at.
Inside, the home is spacious and thoughtfully appointed, with living areas that feel both generous and grounded. Large windows pull in natural light throughout the day, and the interiors strike a balance between modern comfort and the kind of easy coastal sensibility that Montauk does best. Bedrooms are designed for rest, with quality linens and enough space to feel like a retreat within a retreat. The kitchen is fully equipped for those mornings when you would rather cook than go out, and the open layout makes gathering effortless, whether for a quiet breakfast or a long evening with friends. Outdoor spaces extend the living area into the surrounding landscape, with room to dine al fresco, lounge in the sun, or simply sit with the sounds of the pond and the breeze moving through the trees.
Montauk remains one of the most distinctive destinations on the eastern seaboard, a place where surfers, fishermen, artists, and weekenders have long coexisted along a rugged coastline that still feels wild in places. Fort Pond Fantastic places you within easy reach of Ditch Plains, the Montauk Lighthouse, and the town's collection of laid-back restaurants and roadside seafood spots, while keeping you a step removed from the busier stretches of the village. The surrounding area is ideal for cycling, paddleboarding on the pond, or simply driving out to watch the sunset from Camp Hero.
What stays with you about Fort Pond Fantastic is the rhythm it encourages. There is no agenda here, no programming to follow. Just a well-designed home in one of the most beautiful corners of New York, where the days unspool at whatever pace you set for them, and the proximity to water, sky, and open land makes everything feel a little more spacious than it did before you arrived.
Fort Pond Fantastic sits on a quiet stretch of Montauk where the landscape feels unhurried and the water is never far from view. This private residence occupies a privileged position near Fort Pond, one of the area's most serene natural features, offering a sense of seclusion that feels increasingly rare on the East End of Long Island. The architecture is clean and contemporary, designed to frame the surrounding greenery and light rather than compete with it. From the moment you arrive, the property reads as a place built for decompression, where every room opens toward something worth looking at.
Inside, the home is spacious and thoughtfully appointed, with living areas that feel both generous and grounded. Large windows pull in natural light throughout the day, and the interiors strike a balance between modern comfort and the kind of easy coastal sensibility that Montauk does best. Bedrooms are designed for rest, with quality linens and enough space to feel like a retreat within a retreat. The kitchen is fully equipped for those mornings when you would rather cook than go out, and the open layout makes gathering effortless, whether for a quiet breakfast or a long evening with friends. Outdoor spaces extend the living area into the surrounding landscape, with room to dine al fresco, lounge in the sun, or simply sit with the sounds of the pond and the breeze moving through the trees.
Montauk remains one of the most distinctive destinations on the eastern seaboard, a place where surfers, fishermen, artists, and weekenders have long coexisted along a rugged coastline that still feels wild in places. Fort Pond Fantastic places you within easy reach of Ditch Plains, the Montauk Lighthouse, and the town's collection of laid-back restaurants and roadside seafood spots, while keeping you a step removed from the busier stretches of the village. The surrounding area is ideal for cycling, paddleboarding on the pond, or simply driving out to watch the sunset from Camp Hero.
What we love about this stay
There's something about a place that takes its name from the landscape rather than trying to brand over it — Fort Pond Fantastic tells you exactly where its loyalties lie. You feel it the moment you arrive: this is a property shaped by its proximity to Montauk's quieter, pond-side geography, a part of the East End that resists the scene without trying too hard to make a statement about it. The name itself carries a certain unselfconscious confidence, almost playful, suggesting a stay that doesn't take itself too seriously but knows exactly what it's doing. It's the kind of place that lingers in memory not for any single dramatic gesture, but for the rare sense of being somewhere that feels genuinely placed — rooted in a specific corner of a specific town, impossible to relocate.
Explore the residence
Where you'll be staying
What you need to know
4 PM
Not allowed
10 AM
Watch this Stay
Get notified when this stay runs special offers or becomes available during your preferred travel dates. We'll also connect you to the property so you can be eligible for insider rewards and premium experiences.
Follow Fort Pond Fantastic
Follow our social media to gain instant access to all things Fort Pond Fantastic: discounts, photos, updates and giveaways!