Village charm and waterside grandeur in Sag Harbor in Sag Harbor, NY

StayMarquis

Village charm and waterside grandeur in Sag Harbor

Reserve this Stay
Residence in Sag Harbor, NY

Sag Harbor Supreme

18 Guests
9 Bedrooms
9 Beds
10.5 Bathrooms

There is a particular quality to Sag Harbor that sets it apart from the broader Hamptons landscape. The village moves at its own pace, shaped by a whaling-port history that lingers in its clapboard storefronts, its narrow lanes, and the unhurried rhythm of its waterfront. Sag Harbor Supreme sits within this context, a private residence that channels the area's coastal character into a generous, beautifully appointed home designed for gathering, unwinding, and settling into the kind of summer days that seem to stretch well past sundown.

The property offers the space and privacy of a true estate while remaining close to the heart of Sag Harbor village. Interiors are light-filled and thoughtfully composed, balancing classic Hamptons architecture with contemporary comfort. Living areas are expansive enough to host without feeling cavernous, furnished with an eye toward both style and ease. Bedrooms are designed as proper retreats, each with the kind of proportions and finishes that make lingering in bed with morning light feel like a reasonable way to spend an hour. The kitchen anchors the home's social life, outfitted for serious cooking and casual entertaining alike, opening naturally to dining and outdoor spaces where meals can drift from afternoon into evening without anyone checking a clock.

Outdoor living here is central to the experience. The grounds extend the home's footprint into the open air, with a swimming pool serving as the property's warm-weather focal point. Surrounding lounging areas, manicured lawns, and alfresco dining spaces create a sequence of settings that shift with the light and the mood of the day. Whether it is a quiet morning coffee on the terrace or a late-afternoon gathering poolside, the outdoor spaces at Sag Harbor Supreme feel like rooms unto themselves, framed by the lush greenery and soft salt air that define this corner of Long Island's South Fork.

Sag Harbor village is just moments away, offering a Main Street lined with independent bookshops, galleries, and restaurants that reflect the community's creative and literary heritage. The harbor itself invites waterfront walks at dusk, and the broader Hamptons coastline provides access to some of the most celebrated beaches on the East Coast. Yet the true appeal of this residence is the way it gathers all the pleasures of the region and distills them into something private and self-contained. At Sag Harbor Supreme, the days find their own shape, governed by nothing more than the pull of the water, the warmth of the sun, and the rare luxury of time spent without agenda.

What we love about this stay

There's something about the name alone that tells you this place doesn't take itself too seriously, and that's precisely the point. Sag Harbor has always been the quieter, more literary sibling of the Hamptons — a place where taste runs deep but doesn't announce itself — and a property rooted here carries that same energy. You sense it in the way the town holds its character, unhurried and a little stubborn about staying interesting rather than just aspirational. Staying somewhere that leans into Sag Harbor's particular frequency, rather than trying to override it with generic polish, is what makes the difference between a night out east and one that actually lands.

Private Pool

Terrace / Patio

Tennis Court

BBQ / Grill

Free Parking

Fire Extinguisher

Free WiFi

Fresh Towels

Pool Table / Game Room

Outdoor Shower

Smoke & CO Detectors

Explore the residence

18 guests
9 Beds
10.5 Bathrooms

Where you'll be staying

1636 Millstone Road, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, US, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States of America

What you need to know

4 PM

Not allowed

10 AM

Watch this Stay

Get notified when this stay runs special offers or becomes available during your preferred travel dates. We'll also connect you to the property so you can be eligible for insider rewards and premium experiences.

Follow Sag Harbor Supreme

Follow our social media to gain instant access to all things Sag Harbor Supreme: discounts, photos, updates and giveaways!

@staymarquis

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY

TRAVEL WITH JOURNEY